Training to Failure vs Reps in Reserve
Training to failure gives a small edge for muscle growth but little or none for strength, and it costs noticeably more fatigue. For most lifters, stopping one to three repetitions short of failure on most sets is an efficient middle path.
Few gym debates last as long as this one. Recent meta-regressions, a fatigue study and a controlled trial now let us put numbers on what the last repetition buys you and what it costs.
What Training to Failure and Reps in Reserve Mean
Training to failure means continuing a set until you cannot complete another repetition with acceptable technique. Repetitions in reserve, usually shortened to RIR, looks at the same moment from the opposite side: how many clean repetitions you could still have performed when you stopped. A set that ends with two in reserve means you could probably have done about two more. Failure sits at zero on this scale, and an easy warm-up set sits at the far end. Researchers use the scale because it lets them compare very different studies on one axis.
The scale has a weakness: it is an estimate. Lifters judge how many repetitions remain, and that judgement can be wrong, particularly on unfamiliar exercises or early in a training block. One of the studies discussed below lists the unknown accuracy of predicted repetitions in reserve as a limitation. Treat a target such as two in reserve as an approximate guide rather than a precise measurement. Practising the estimate over several weeks, and checking it occasionally by taking a safe set to true failure, can help you calibrate.
Why does any of this matter? Because the final repetitions of a hard set are the most tiring part of a workout, and pushing every set to failure has a price that shows up later in the session and sometimes in the days afterwards. The practical question is whether the extra effort buys enough extra muscle or strength to justify that price. Recent research gives a fairly clear answer for strength and a more nuanced one for muscle size, which the next sections explain.
What the 2024 Meta-Regression Found
A 2024 paper in Sports Medicine by Zac Robinson and colleagues pooled many training studies in a series of meta-regressions. Instead of splitting studies into failure versus not failure, this approach treats proximity to failure as a continuous scale. For strength, the authors found a negligible relationship: lifters became stronger by similar amounts whether their sets ended far from failure or close to it. That is a useful result, because it means you do not have to grind out every set to build strength.
Muscle size told a different story. In the same analysis, changes in muscle size increased as sets were terminated closer to failure, which points to a dose-dependent relationship for hypertrophy. In plain terms, sets that ended with fewer repetitions in reserve tended to be linked with more growth. A university summary of the work describes a range of about 0 to 5 repetitions short of failure for muscle growth, and about 3 to 5 short of failure when strength is the main goal.
The authors are careful about what this means. Because repetitions in reserve were estimated rather than measured in many of the included studies, they note that the exact relationship between RIR and both hypertrophy and strength remains unclear. The finding describes a trend across studies, not a guarantee for any individual lifter. It also cannot tell you that the very last repetition is the decisive one, which is why direct comparisons of failure and non-failure training are worth looking at next.
The Fatigue Cost of Reaching Failure
A 2023 study in Sports Medicine – Open by Martin Refalo and colleagues measured what closeness to failure costs in fatigue. Twenty-four resistance-trained people, 12 men and 12 women, performed six sets of bench press in three conditions: to momentary failure, stopping with one repetition in reserve, or stopping with three in reserve. The researchers tracked barbell velocity, a sensitive marker of neuromuscular fatigue, before and after each session to see how far performance dropped.
Four minutes after training, bar velocity had fallen by 25% after sets to failure, compared with 13% after one in reserve and 8% after three in reserve. Fatigue rose in a linear way as sets moved closer to failure. Within a session, velocity fell from the first to the final set by 22% when training to failure, 9% at one in reserve and 6% at three in reserve. In other words, each extra repetition you leave in the tank noticeably reduces how much fatigue you carry forward.
Recovery was quick in this setup. At 24 hours, the failure and one-in-reserve conditions were only about 3% below baseline, and by 48 hours all three conditions had fully recovered. Men showed more fatigue than women after sets to failure, 29% versus 21% at four minutes, but the sexes did not differ at one or three in reserve. The study tested only the bench press and only six sets, so it cannot describe every exercise, but it supports leaving a rep or two in reserve.
A Controlled Trial: Failure Versus Two in Reserve
Thomas Hermann, Brad Schoenfeld and colleagues tested the question directly in a randomized trial, published in Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise in 2025. Forty-two resistance-trained men and women followed single-set routines for eight weeks. One group took every set to failure, while the other stopped each set with two repetitions in reserve. Using single sets keeps total training volume low, which makes effort the main difference between the groups rather than the number of sets completed.
Both groups made appreciable gains in most outcomes. Several measures of muscle growth tended to favour the failure group, but the absolute differences were generally modest, while strength and local muscular endurance improved similarly in both groups. The failure group also showed some advantage in jumping ability. So the extra effort bought a small edge in some measures of size and power, and nothing measurable for maximal strength or muscular endurance.
This fits the meta-regression well: a slight hypertrophy advantage close to failure and little difference for strength. It also shows that minimal training can work, since even single sets produced appreciable gains in trained lifters. As with any small trial, 42 people over eight weeks cannot settle the matter. The results may not transfer to beginners, older adults or much higher training volumes, and individual responses will vary from person to person.
How to Use This in Your Own Training
A sensible default for most lifters is to finish the majority of working sets with roughly one to three repetitions in reserve and to save true failure for occasional sets. The evidence supports this middle path: strength shows little sensitivity to proximity to failure, and the added muscle growth from failure appears modest while the fatigue cost is clear. Staying a little short also makes it easier to repeat quality sessions through the week.
Failure is easier to justify on exercises where a missed repetition is safe and technique does not fall apart, such as leg extensions, cable work or machine presses. It is harder to justify on heavy barbell squats, or on a bench press without a spotter, where fatigue can compromise form. Ending isolation exercises at or near failure while keeping heavy compound lifts a couple of repetitions short is a reasonable compromise that many lifters find easy to manage.
Whatever you choose, record the load, repetitions and how hard each set felt so you can progress over time. If performance drops week after week or your joints ache, you may be pushing too hard too often, and a lighter week from our deload guide could help. If you have a medical condition, an injury or are returning after a long break, speak with a doctor or qualified coach before increasing training intensity.
Your Proximity-to-Failure Checklist
- check_circleStep 1 — Stop most working sets with one to three repetitions in reserve.
- check_circleStep 2 — Save true failure for safe exercises such as machines and cables.
- check_circleStep 3 — Keep heavy barbell lifts a couple of reps short, especially without a spotter.
- check_circleStep 4 — Calibrate your estimate by occasionally taking a safe set to failure.
- check_circleStep 5 — Log load, reps and effort so progress is measurable.
- check_circleStep 6 — Schedule a lighter week if performance keeps falling.
"Strength barely cares how close to failure you train. Muscle size cares a little. Fatigue cares a lot."
— Calorie Fit Team
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to train to failure to build muscle?
No. Research suggests that training closer to failure is associated with somewhat more muscle growth, but the advantage is modest, and trained lifters in a controlled trial still made appreciable gains when they stopped two repetitions short of failure.
Is training to failure better for strength?
No. The 2024 meta-regression found a negligible relationship between proximity to failure and strength gains, and strength increased similarly in the failure and two-in-reserve groups of the 2025 trial.
How many reps in reserve should I aim for?
A practical starting point is one to three repetitions in reserve on most sets, with the occasional set taken to failure on safe exercises. Because your estimate may be imperfect, treat the number as a guide and adjust based on how you recover.
Is training to failure dangerous?
It is not inherently dangerous, but it increases fatigue and can make technique slip, which matters most on heavy free-weight lifts. Use machines, cables or a spotter when you push close to failure, and talk to a doctor or coach if you have an injury or health condition.
Sources
- Exploring the dose-response relationship between estimated resistance training proximity to failure, strength gain, and muscle hypertrophy: a series of meta-regressions — Sports Medicine, 2024
- Influence of Resistance Training Proximity-to-Failure, Determined by Repetitions-in-Reserve, on Neuromuscular Fatigue in Resistance-Trained Males and Females — Sports Medicine – Open, 2023
- Without fail: Muscular adaptations in single set resistance training performed to failure or with repetitions-in-reserve — SportRxiv (preprint of the paper in Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise), 2024
- For Bigger Muscles Push Close to Failure, For Strength, Maybe Not — Florida Atlantic University, 2024
Educational information, not medical advice. See our Medical Disclaimer and Editorial Policy for how we research and verify articles.