TDEE Calculator Macro Calculator BMI Calculator All Calculators
Blog
TRAINING ECCENTRIC TRAINING MUSCLE GROWTH

Eccentric vs Concentric Training for Muscle

account_circle Calorie Fit
calendar_today November 12, 2026
schedule 8 min read
Close-up of a lifter's hands gripping a loaded barbell on a power rack in a dim gym with chalk on the floor

Training the lowering phase of a lift (eccentric) builds muscle about as well as training the lifting phase (concentric), though eccentric work may give a specific edge for eccentric strength. The most recent meta-analyses find no clear hypertrophy winner, so the best approach is to train both phases well.

Negatives, slow lowering and accentuated eccentrics are popular, and some coaches claim they are the secret to growth. Here is what pooled trials really show for muscle size, strength and health markers, and how to use the lowering phase without adding needless soreness.

26
STUDIES IN A 2025 HYPERTROPHY META-ANALYSIS ★
682 healthy adults, no clear size difference
27% vs 10%
ECCENTRIC STRENGTH GAIN, ECCENTRIC-ONLY VS CONCENTRIC-ONLY
27 randomised trials, 2025
13% vs 14%
CONCENTRIC STRENGTH GAIN, SAME COMPARISON
No meaningful difference
20
TRIALS IN THE 2009 ROIG REVIEW
Higher-load eccentric work gave larger strength gains

Two halves of every repetition

Every repetition has two main halves. In the concentric phase the muscle shortens while it overcomes the weight, such as standing up from a squat. In the eccentric phase the muscle lengthens under tension while it controls the weight, such as lowering into that squat or lowering a dumbbell during a curl. A third kind of contraction, isometric, happens when the muscle produces force without changing length, such as pausing at the bottom of a squat.

Muscles can produce more force eccentrically than concentrically, which is why you can lower a weight you could not lift. Eccentric work also demands less energy and muscle activation for the same force. These differences led researchers to ask whether training the lowering phase specifically might drive more growth. That mechanical advantage is also why heavy negatives can be done with weights above your lifting maximum, and why they are usually done with a spotter or machine.

The theory is reasonable, but theory and results do not always match. Long-running reviews have compared programmes that use only eccentric actions, only concentric actions, or a mix, in healthy adults. Their findings are more nuanced than the claim that negatives are simply superior for building muscle. The sections below take the evidence in turn: muscle size first, then strength, then soreness and the limits of the studies, and finally health markers. Each outcome tells a slightly different story, so it helps to keep them separate.

Muscle size: no clear winner

A 2025 meta-analysis in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research by da Silva and colleagues identified 15,778 studies and included 26 trials with 682 healthy adults. The main finding was no statistically significant difference between eccentric and concentric training for hypertrophy, with a pooled effect of 0.285 and a confidence interval that crossed zero. A confidence interval that crosses zero means the data are compatible with eccentric training being better, equal or even slightly worse, so the honest summary is that the review could not separate them.

Subgroup analyses by age and by programme length beyond eight weeks also found no differences. Some subgroups leaned toward eccentric training, including upper-limb muscles, programmes of eight weeks or less, and muscle thickness measurements, so the authors noted that eccentric work may be favoured in some situations. These leanings are worth noting, but each subgroup contains fewer trials than the full analysis, so any pattern is more fragile. Splitting data many ways also raises the chance of finding something that looks meaningful but is really just noise.

The certainty of the evidence was rated very low and the trials varied a lot, so no strong conclusion is justified. In practice, the safest reading is that both phases can grow muscle. Choosing a programme you can repeat, progress and recover from will matter more than which phase you emphasise. Very low certainty means that future studies could easily change the picture in either direction, so the conclusion should be revisited as better trials appear. Until then, the absence of a clear winner is itself useful information, because it suggests lifters do not need to build a programme around a single phase.

Strength: where eccentric work stands out

Strength is a different story. A 2025 meta-analysis in Sports Medicine – Open by Spudić and Nosaka pooled 27 randomised trials comparing eccentric-only and concentric-only isokinetic training. Maximal eccentric strength rose by 27 percent after eccentric training compared with 10 percent after concentric training. Isokinetic training uses a machine that controls the speed of movement, which allows researchers to measure force very precisely at set speeds. That precision is a strength of these studies, but it also means they differ from the free-weight lifting most people do.

For concentric strength the picture was equal: gains were 13 percent after eccentric-only training and 14 percent after concentric-only training. Isometric strength rose by 18 percent and 17 percent. In other words, eccentric work was clearly better at improving eccentric strength, and it did not hurt the other types. This pattern fits the idea of specificity: training a given type of contraction improves that type most. Eccentric-only training is also a narrow comparison, since it was tested against concentric-only training rather than against the mixed training most lifters do.

This echoes an older 2009 review in the British Journal of Sports Medicine by Roig and colleagues, which pooled 20 trials. It found that higher-intensity eccentric work produced larger gains in total and eccentric strength, and that strength gains were quite specific to the velocity and type of contraction that was trained. The same message appearing in a review published many years earlier is reassuring, because it suggests the finding does not depend on one particular dataset.

Soreness, specificity and what the evidence cannot tell us

The strength results come with caveats. In the 2025 analysis the certainty of evidence was rated low for eccentric strength and very low for the other measures, and the studies varied widely. Most trials used single-joint isokinetic machines, which are rare in ordinary gyms, so the findings may not transfer neatly to squats, rows or presses. Low certainty means the true effect may differ noticeably from the reported figure, so the 27 percent and 10 percent values are better read as a direction than as a precise forecast.

Participants were mostly untrained or moderately trained, aged about 20 to 38, and only one study included strength-trained people. The review was also not pre-registered. Pre-registration means writing down the plan before the analysis begins, which limits the temptation to choose methods after seeing the data. Its absence does not make the findings wrong, but it removes one safeguard. These details mean the results are best treated as a guide for beginners and recreational lifters rather than a rule for advanced athletes.

There is also a practical cost. Roig and colleagues noted that unaccustomed eccentric exercise causes transient muscle damage, soreness and loss of force, especially in older adults, and called for caution. Eccentric work is demanding on recovery, so introduce it gradually, and leave time between hard sessions. Soreness after an unfamiliar eccentric session can make the next workout harder, which may reduce the total training you manage over a week. That is one reason a gradual build-up is wiser than adding a large block of negatives at once.

Health markers and practical use

Eccentric exercise has also been studied for health. A 2023 review in the Journal of Sports Science and Medicine by Ansari and colleagues pooled 19 trials with 618 sedentary adults or people with metabolic disease. Eccentric training did not improve glucose handling, measured by HbA1c, compared with concentric training. HbA1c reflects average blood sugar over the previous few months, which makes it a useful measure of longer-term glucose control. The absence of an advantage for eccentric training on this marker is worth noting, particularly for anyone hoping to use it to manage diabetes.

It did show benefits elsewhere. Overall muscle strength increased, with a standardised difference of 0.70, and systolic blood pressure fell by 6.84 mmHg more, with diastolic pressure down 6.39 mmHg more, compared with concentric work. The authors still called for additional high-quality trials to confirm these results. Blood pressure changes of this size are potentially meaningful for people with raised blood pressure, but the review pooled people with different conditions, so the size of benefit for any one person is uncertain.

For most lifters the practical message is straightforward. Control the lowering phase instead of dropping the weight, use a deliberate, steady descent if it suits you, and keep both phases in your programme. Consider heavier eccentric work only once you have a base and a recovery plan. A controlled descent costs nothing, needs no special equipment and fits any programme, so it is the easiest change to make. Log your load, repetitions and soreness for a few weeks, and only then decide whether extra eccentric sets are earning their place in your routine.

Using the lowering phase well

  • check_circleControl every descent — lower the weight under control rather than letting gravity do the work.
  • check_circleKeep both phases — train lifting and lowering together, since the evidence shows no clear hypertrophy winner.
  • check_circleEase into negatives — start with a small number of extra eccentric sets to limit soreness and recovery costs.
  • check_circleUse a spotter for heavy negatives — never attempt supramaximal lowering alone.
  • check_circleAllow recovery — leave extra time before training the same muscle hard again after a new eccentric stimulus.
  • check_circleTrack your progress — log load, repetitions and soreness to see whether the extra eccentric work pays off.
  • check_circleGet advice if needed — older adults and people with health conditions should ask a professional before adding heavy eccentric work.

"Our findings suggest similar hypertrophy between eccentric and concentric muscle actions in apparently healthy adults."

— da Silva et al., Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 2025

Frequently Asked Questions

Are negative reps better for building muscle?

Not clearly. A 2025 meta-analysis of 26 trials and 682 healthy adults found no statistically significant difference in hypertrophy between eccentric and concentric training. Some subgroups leaned toward eccentric work, but the certainty of the evidence was rated very low.

Does eccentric training build more strength?

It builds more eccentric strength. A 2025 meta-analysis found eccentric-only training raised eccentric strength by 27 percent versus 10 percent for concentric-only training, while concentric and isometric strength gains were similar between the two approaches.

Why am I so sore after lowering heavy weights?

Unaccustomed eccentric exercise tends to cause temporary muscle damage, soreness and loss of force, according to a 2009 review. Soreness usually eases as you adapt, so introduce eccentric work gradually and talk to a professional if pain is severe or lasts.

Can eccentric training help blood pressure?

A 2023 meta-analysis of 19 trials with 618 sedentary adults or people with metabolic disease found larger reductions in blood pressure after eccentric training than after concentric training. The authors said more high-quality trials are needed, so check with a doctor before using it as treatment.

Sources

  1. Comparison Between Eccentric vs. Concentric Muscle Actions On Hypertrophy: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis — Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 2025
  2. Eccentric-Only Versus Concentric-Only Isokinetic Strength Training Effects on Maximal Voluntary Eccentric, Concentric and Isometric Contraction Strength: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis — Sports Medicine – Open, 2025
  3. The effects of eccentric versus concentric resistance training on muscle strength and mass in healthy adults: a systematic review with meta-analysis — British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2009
  4. The Health and Functional Benefits of Eccentric versus Concentric Exercise Training: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis — Journal of Sports Science and Medicine, 2023

Educational information, not medical advice. See our Medical Disclaimer and Editorial Policy for how we research and verify articles.